A good "Why us" essay connects something specific about the student with something specific about the university, and is true only for that student–university pair. The simplest test: replace the university's name with another of the same standing; if the essay is still true, it has not done its job. Most "Why us" essays fail not because they are badly written but because the research behind them is too shallow, stopping at rankings, location and the welcome text on the home page.
Many US universities ask for this kind of essay among their supplementary essays, usually with a much shorter limit than the main essay. This article goes through how Global Gate Pass mentors guide students to research a university, how to choose two or three points of connection, how to build the essay within a short limit, and the mistakes that make a "Why us" essay invisible. Ms Lâm Hà Phương, the mentor in charge of the US and Canada, leads the supplementary essay work for North American applications.
What a university wants to learn by asking "Why us"
The surface question is "why did you choose this university", but what the university wants to know at a deeper level is: does the student understand the university well enough to know what they will do there, and what will the student contribute to the campus community. Some universities also use this kind of essay to gauge the student's genuine interest — is the student applying because they really want to come, or just because the university is on a ranking list.
That explains why sentences such as "the university has an excellent programme", "experienced faculty" or "a diverse environment" are almost worthless. The university already knows these things about itself. The question is how the student will use them, and how specifically.
From a mentor's point of view, "Why us" is also a test of the university list. If a student cannot write a good "Why us" essay for a university after researching it carefully, that may be a sign the university is not really a good fit, and it is worth reconsidering whether to apply. Global Gate Pass builds university lists so that each one has its own reason, so the "Why us" essay usually grows out of that very reason.
Researching one university in three to four hours
The mentor gives the student a structured research process for each university that needs a "Why us" essay. The aim is not to read everything but to find genuine points of connection.
- Read the structure of the intended major: required courses, electives, whether there are narrower concentrations, whether a capstone project is required. Note two or three courses the student genuinely wants to take, and why.
- Look into the general education curriculum or requirements outside the major: some universities have a tightly structured liberal arts core, others allow almost complete freedom. This affects how the student will study.
- Look at undergraduate research opportunities: whether the university has programmes for first-year students to join research, and how to apply.
- Read about student life: clubs, student organisations, housing, the university's own traditions. Choose those that connect with activities the student is already doing.
- Find out about distinctive programmes: exchange semesters, required internships, co-op work semesters, interdisciplinary centres.
- Attend the university's online information session if there is one, and note the questions that students and admissions staff answer — sometimes a small detail here becomes the best point of connection.
- Put everything into a table with three columns: something specific about the university, something specific about the student, and the connection between the two.
Students often skip the last step and just collect information. The three-column table forces them to think about the connection, and it is the connection, not the information about the university, that is the content of the essay.
Weak connections and strong connections
The table below illustrates the difference between a generic connection and a specific one, for a hypothetical student who wants to study environmental science. Programme names are written generically because this is an example, not information about a particular university.
| Weak connection | Stronger connection | Why it is stronger |
|---|---|---|
| The university has a good environmental science major | A second-year fieldwork course on urban water systems, linked to the student's own measurements of turbidity in the canal near home | Shows the student has read the curriculum and has a personal reason |
| The university has many research opportunities | A summer research programme for first-year students, where the student wants to continue a question about rainwater and pollution | A concrete plan, connected to what the student is already doing |
| The university is in a big city with many opportunities | Its location near the city's water management projects, where students can intern | The location reason is tied to an academic goal, not just a preference |
| The university has a diverse student community | A student club running clean water projects in communities, where the student can contribute experience from a project back home | Shows what the student will bring, not only what they will receive |
A strong connection always has two halves: something specific about the university and something specific about the student. Without either half, the connection becomes generic.
Building the essay within a short limit
The limit for a "Why us" essay is usually much shorter than for the main essay; some universities allow a few hundred words, others only about a hundred or fewer. With a short limit, the structure has to be tight: one opening sentence that connects the student directly with the university, the two or three strongest connections developed, and one closing sentence about what the student will bring. There is no room for a lead-in or a long opening scene.
A common mistake is trying to cram in as many details about the university as possible, turning the essay into a list of course names, club names and programme names. An essay like that shows the student has done research, but not what the student thinks. Mentors advise choosing fewer connections and going deeper: two connections with clearly explained reasons are better than six that are merely named.
The closing sentence of a "Why us" essay should look ahead to what the student will do or bring, not repeat that they would love to be admitted. A specific closing line — which group they will join, which question they will continue, what skill they will contribute to a campus activity — leaves the impression of someone who can already picture themselves there, rather than someone asking to be let in.
For universities that combine "why this university and why this major", the essay needs to balance motivation for the subject with reasons for choosing that particular university. Students tend to write too much about the subject — because that part is easier — and too little about the university. Mentors ask for at least half the essay to be about things that are true only of that university.
Mistakes that make a "Why us" essay invisible
Praising the university. The essay is full of adjectives extolling the university. The university does not need praise; it needs to know what the student will do there.
Mentioning rankings and prestige. Saying the university is highly ranked or famous is the quickest way to show the student has not researched deeply, and it accidentally suggests the student chose it for its name.
Talking only about the city, the weather, the campus. These reasons may be genuine but have nothing to do with studying. If mentioned, they should only be mentioned when they connect to an academic goal or activity.
Name-dropping professors superficially. Naming a professor without explaining why their work relates to the student often backfires. At undergraduate level, it is better to talk about programmes, courses and opportunities than about individual faculty members.
Reusing one essay for many universities with only the name changed. Readers notice immediately when the details are too generic, and the biggest risk is forgetting to change the university's name in one place — a mistake that happens more often than students imagine.
Copying the university's own marketing text. The university's promotional language sitting in a student's essay sounds out of place and shows the student only skimmed.
An illustrative case: writing "Why us" essays for ten universities in one season
A hypothetical case: a student applies to ten universities in the US, seven of which require a "Why us" essay with different limits. He starts by writing one general essay that he plans to adapt for each university. After three essays, he realises they all sound the same and none of the universities stands out.
The mentor suggests a change of approach: spend one session per university filling in the three-column table first, without writing anything. Once he has seven tables, he can clearly see that two universities have very few genuine connections; after talking it over with his family, he drops one university from the list and replaces another with one whose programme fits better. The remaining five each have their own connections, and the essays come out of those far faster than adapting the general essay would have.
The division of work changes too. Instead of writing seven essays at once, he works in order of deadline, two essays a week, starting with the university he understands best so that he has a good model essay to set the standard for the rest. Universities with very similar questions are written back to back so he does not have to switch mental gears too often, but each essay still comes out of that university's own three-column table. The mentor reads each essay with a single question: if the university's name were changed, would the essay still be true?
The lesson from this case is not only about writing. The "Why us" essay forces the student to research each university seriously, and that process sometimes changes the list itself — which is good for the student, because in the end he will spend four years at one of those universities.
Frequently asked questions
Should an undergraduate "Why us" essay name professors?
It can, but only when the student has read about that professor's work and has a specific reason. At undergraduate level, professors may go on leave, move to another university or not teach first-year students, so building the whole essay around one person is risky. Talking about programmes, courses and research opportunities is usually safer and more convincing.
Can a student write a good "Why us" essay without ever having visited the university?
Yes. Most international students have not visited the university before applying, and admissions readers know that. Online information sessions, department pages, student blog posts on the university's website and conversations with alumni are enough to find genuine connections.
Should the essay mention that an older sibling or an acquaintance studied there?
It can, if their experience helped the student understand the university better and leads to a specific connection. But the essay should not rely on that relationship, because the university wants to know why the student themselves is a good fit. One sentence is enough; the rest should be about the student.
Is the "Why us" essay as important as the main essay?
How important it is varies by university, but at highly selective universities supplementary essays are read closely and can be what distinguishes between comparable applications. In addition, a weak "Why us" essay suggests the student is not really interested in the university — a signal that can affect the overall assessment.
Is it fine to write a quick "Why us" essay for a safety school?
No. Safety schools still read the essay and still assess interest, especially when considering scholarships. Students admitted to a safety school are often strong candidates there, and a careless essay throws away that advantage exactly when the university is deciding who deserves extra support.