GlobalGatePass.comGlobal Gate Pass
Master's, PhD and research applications

Choosing a lab before you apply for a PhD: read the papers, ask the doctoral students, watch for signs

Choosing a lab means choosing the people you will work with for years: read its recent papers, talk to current doctoral students, and check funding and supervision style before you apply.

Choosing a lab before you apply for a PhD: read the papers, ask the doctoral students, watch for signs

Choosing the right lab means choosing a supervisor and a group you will work with for three to six years, not choosing the name of a university. Global Gate Pass mentors use four sources to assess a lab: its papers from the last few years (its real direction and who the lead authors are), the lab page and member list (current doctoral students, and where former members have gone), its sources of funding, and direct conversations with doctoral students currently in the lab. Those four sources answer the most important question of all: can the student produce a thesis in this environment?

Many families and students choose by university ranking and only then look for a professor at that university. At doctoral level this order is often the wrong way round. A well-matched professor at a mid-ranked university can give a student a good thesis, a good network and a weighty reference letter, while a poorly matched lab at a prestigious university can leave a student dragging on for years. This article walks through how mentors read a lab and the questions worth asking before you put a professor's name in your application.

Reading a lab's papers: look at direction, not just quantity

The first step is always to read the list of papers from the last few years on the lab page or in an academic database. Mentors guide students to read in three layers, each answering a different question.

The first layer is topic. What questions do the recent papers revolve around? Do they match the question the student wants to work on? If a student reads an excellent old paper and chooses the lab on that basis, but the lab has moved in another direction over the past five years, the match exists only on paper.

The second layer is author position. In many natural science and engineering fields, the first author is usually the person who did the main work and the last author is usually the professor in charge. If many papers have doctoral students as first authors, that is a sign that doctoral students in the lab get to run their own projects and publish them. If the first author is always a postdoctoral researcher or the professor, you need to ask more about the role of doctoral students. Authorship conventions differ between fields, so the regional mentor reads alongside the student to avoid drawing the wrong conclusions.

The third layer is publication rhythm. A lab that publishes steadily over the years shows stable activity. A long gap may be because the professor was on leave, changed university, moved into management, or the lab ran out of funding. There is nothing wrong with any of those reasons, but the student needs to know in advance.

After reading all three layers, the student writes a short paragraph describing the lab in their own words. If they cannot, they do not yet understand the lab well enough to name it in their statement of purpose.

What the lab page and member list tell you

The number of current doctoral students. A lab with very few people may be new, or the professor may take few students; a very large lab may mean each person has little time with the professor, and day-to-day supervision falls to postdoctoral researchers. There is no right number, only a number that suits how each person learns.

Where former members have gone. Many labs record where their graduated doctoral students now work. This list shows whether the lab is strong at placing people in academia or in industry, and how long it takes to graduate if start and finish years are given.

Whether there are international or Vietnamese doctoral students. This is not a required criterion, but a lab used to supervising foreigners usually has experience with visa procedures, language and the adjustment period.

Whether the lab updates its page regularly. A lab page that has not been updated for a long time does not mean the lab is weak, but it does mean the student will have to ask directly more often to find out the current situation.

Whether there are recruitment notices. Many labs state clearly that they are recruiting doctoral students for a particular project with a particular deadline. This is the most valuable information of all, because it is tied to funding that already exists.

Funding: a question not to be shy about

At doctoral level, funding decides a great deal: whether the student has their tuition waived and receives a salary or stipend, and whether there is money for conferences, equipment and fieldwork. Funding can come from university scholarships, from a research project the professor has won, from a government or organisational scholarship the applicant brings with them, or from a combination.

Mentors guide students to look for funding information in this order: the department's admissions page (general funding policy), the lab's recruitment notices (project-funded positions), and only then the professor, once there has been some exchange. A question about funding asked at the right moment is a professional question, not a tactless one. The professor also needs to know whether the applicant has their own funding in order to plan.

Pay particular attention to how long the funding lasts compared with the expected time to complete the thesis. If project funding only covers three years while theses in the field usually take longer, the student needs to ask about the plan for the remainder: teaching assistantships, a completion scholarship, or self-funding.

Applicants who bring their own scholarship (a host-government scholarship, a bilateral agreement scholarship, an international fund) are often welcomed more readily by professors because they cost the lab nothing. For students applying for these scholarships, the mentor schedules contact with professors in parallel with the scholarship timetable, because many schemes require a supervisor's letter of acceptance in the scholarship application.

Talking to doctoral students currently in the lab: what to ask

Once the professor has replied positively, mentors usually advise the student to ask permission to speak to a current doctoral student. This is the most honest source of information about life in the lab. The questions mentors suggest preparing:

  1. What does a typical working week in the lab look like, and how often are group meetings?
  2. How does the professor give feedback on drafts, and how long does it take?
  3. Do doctoral students choose their own topics or are they given a topic within a project?
  4. What do first-year doctoral students usually do: take courses, teach, or join a project straight away?
  5. Does the lab offer opportunities for conferences, internships or collaboration with other groups?
  6. What do newcomers to the lab tend to find difficult?
  7. If you could choose again, would you join this lab again, and why?

The answers should be heard with some caution. One person may be going through a difficult period of their own; speak to two people if you can. The student should not pass on what doctoral students have told them to anyone else, and should not quote it in their application. The purpose of the conversation is to help the student decide for themselves, not to collect material for writing.

Signs that call for more questions before you choose

No single sign is enough on its own to rule out a lab. Mentors treat them as amber flags: when you see one, ask more until it is clear, and only then decide.

SignPossible reasonWhat to ask
Doctoral students graduate later than is typical for the fieldA difficult topic, lack of funding, or uneven supervisionHow long recent graduates took, and why
Many people leave the lab part-way throughA change in personal direction, or an environment that did not suit themWhat those who left went on to do, whether they keep in touch
The professor is about to retire or move universityA normal career planIs there a co-supervisor, how will doctoral students be looked after
The professor holds many management rolesThe lab is large and has several day-to-day supervisorsWho will meet the doctoral student each week
No papers by doctoral students for several yearsThe field publishes slowly, or doctoral students rarely run main projectsAt what stage doctoral students usually publish

Vietnamese students are often reluctant to ask questions like these for fear of seeming demanding. Mentors remind them that in Western academic settings, an applicant who asks carefully about ways of working is usually seen as serious. What matters is how you ask: ask in order to understand, not to pass judgement.

When two labs invite you: the decision frame mentors use

A situation mentors often come across, by way of illustration: a biology student receives encouragement to apply from two professors. The first professor is at a better-known university, has a large lab and a project close to what the student wants, but the work set aside for a newcomer is a small piece of a large project. The second professor is at a university less well known in Vietnam, has a small lab and a project the student would lead from the start, and the doctoral students in the lab say the professor meets each of them every week. This is a scenario constructed for illustration.

The mentor does not choose for the student but asks four questions. First, does the student learn better with clear structure or with autonomy? Second, does the student want to continue in academia or move into industry, and which lab has a track record of sending people in that direction? Third, whose funding is more secure and lasts longer? Fourth, can the student picture working with this person every week for years?

The fourth question is often skipped but frequently decides the matter. After the video call with each professor, the mentor suggests the student write down straight away their impressions of how the professor listened, how they asked questions and how they spoke about their doctoral students. These notes are valuable when the time comes to choose.

At Global Gate Pass, the regional mentor for the destination country reads labs together with the student, while Dương Bảo Khánh, who is responsible for Alumni and careers, helps students think about where the thesis will lead. If you have a list of labs and are not sure how to read them, you can book a free 60-minute first consultation through the form on our Contact page.

Frequently asked questions

Should I choose the university or the professor first when applying for a PhD?

At doctoral level it is usually better to start from your research question and a well-matched professor, then consider the university. The supervisor and research group affect your thesis more than the university's overall ranking, although the university's reputation is still a factor.

How can I tell whether a lab still has funding to take on doctoral students?

Look at recruitment notices on the lab page and the department's funding policy, and ask the professor after an initial exchange. Positions tied to a funded project are usually advertised with a specific funding period.

Should I ask to speak to doctoral students currently in the lab?

Yes, once the professor has replied positively. This is the most honest source of information about how the lab works. Ask politely, ask in order to understand, and if possible talk to two people for a more balanced view.

Is a large lab or a small lab better for a doctoral student?

There is no general answer. Large labs usually have more resources and day-to-day support, while small labs usually offer more direct time with the professor and more autonomy. Choose according to how you learn and what you want to do after the PhD.

Should I choose a professor who is about to retire as my supervisor?

You can, if there is a clear co-supervision plan and enough funding for the whole thesis period. Ask the professor directly about this plan before applying rather than guessing from information online.

How does Global Gate Pass help with choosing a lab?

The regional mentor reads papers, lab pages and funding policies with the student, prepares questions for video calls with professors and doctoral students, and uses a decision frame when there are several options. The final decision belongs to the student.

Need specific advice for your case?

We will contact you within 24 hours.

Request consultation now

Related articles

Need more help?

Leave your details and we will get back to you within 24 hours.