A graduate employment rate is only worth trusting when it answers four questions: how long after graduation the survey was taken, what percentage of students responded, how "employed" is defined, and whether the figures are broken down by field and for international students. The ninety per cent on an admissions page may be very reliable, or it may say almost nothing, depending on those four answers.
A Global Gate Pass mentor reads outcomes reports at programme level, not school level, and sets them against the career path the student intends to take: staying on to work for a while, continuing to study, or returning to Vietnam. This article explains the sources of outcomes data in each country, where international students tend to be missing from the figures, and the questions worth asking.
Four questions before trusting an employment rate
How long after graduation was the survey? A survey three months after graduation and one fifteen months after graduation give two different pictures. The earlier the survey, the lower the employment rate, but it reflects how well the programme prepares students; a later survey shows how settled graduates become.
What percentage responded? If only a small share of students answered the survey, the figure may be skewed: those with good jobs are usually more willing to respond. A trustworthy report always gives the response rate; if it does not, ask.
What does "employed" include? Some reports count part-time work, jobs unrelated to the field, or combine "employed or in further study" into one figure. Combining them is not wrong, but you need to know in order to read it correctly. The more important question is what percentage are in full-time work in or close to their field.
Are the figures broken down by field and for international students? The whole-school rate hides very large differences between fields. And if the survey mainly covers domestic students, the figure may not reflect the situation of international students, which also depends on post-study work visa rules.
Sources of outcomes data in the countries Vietnamese students often choose
Each country collects data differently. Knowing the source helps you read the figure correctly and know whether it can be compared between schools.
| Country | Main source | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| UK | The national Graduate Outcomes survey, run by HESA | Taken about fifteen months after graduation, with the same method for every institution, so schools can be compared |
| Australia | The Graduate Outcomes Survey within the QILT suite | Taken a few months after graduation, with figures by study area and a comparison tool on the QILT website |
| US | Each school's "first destination" report, many following NACE standards | Each school publishes its own, with very different levels of detail; read the definitions and response rate carefully |
| Canada | Each school's reports, with shared surveys in some provinces | Co-op programmes often publish the number of paid work terms, which is very useful information |
| Europe, East Asia | Reports from each school or department | Little standardisation; you often have to ask the department or careers office directly |
With national sources such as those in the UK and Australia, comparing schools has a firmer basis because the method is the same. With figures each school publishes itself, comparing two schools' numbers means comparing two different definitions, so be careful.
International students are often missing from the figures
A point families rarely notice: many outcomes surveys have a low response rate among international students, or only survey students who remain in the host country. Students who have gone home often do not respond, or are not included in the analysis. As a result, the outcomes figure mainly reflects the situation of domestic students, who do not need a visa to work.
For Vietnamese students, real outcomes also depend on three factors the report does not mention: the host country's post-study work visa rules at the time of graduation, whether the field is one where employers are willing to sponsor, and the student's own plan. Post-study visa rules change with policy over time, so the mentor always checks the immigration authority's official website and promises nothing in advance about staying on.
So when reading a report, the mentor also asks the careers office: are there separate figures for international students, where do international students in this field usually do internships, and what specific support does the school offer those who need a visa? The answer to this question often says more than the overall rate.
Reading employer lists and internships
Admissions pages often list the big employers that have hired the school's students. These lists look good but carry little information: a large company that hired one student in five years can still appear. What is worth asking is how many students from this field go to work at those places each year, and whether employers come to campus to recruit directly.
Internships are a better indicator. A programme with a compulsory internship or an alternating study-and-work model gives students real experience before graduating, and many students get job offers from the place they interned. The mentor asks: what share of students have at least one internship, how the school helps find placements, whether international students can take full part, and whether internships are paid.
For students planning to return to Vietnam, the mentor also asks about the alumni network in Vietnam and the region, and whether internships can be done in Vietnam. These factors rarely appear in reports, but they have a big effect on finding work after returning.
Questions to send the careers office
When the published report is not enough, a short email to the careers office or the department usually gets an answer. These are the questions mentors often use; pick the three or four that fit best:
- What percentage of graduates from this programme are in full-time work related to their field about six months after graduating, and what was the survey response rate?
- Are there separate figures for international students?
- What percentage of students in this programme complete at least one internship before graduating?
- How does the school support international students in finding internships and jobs, and are there separate sessions on work regulations?
- Could you put me in touch with an international alumnus of the programme to ask more?
How the school answers is also information. An office that replies specifically, with figures, and is willing to connect you with alumni is usually an office that works well for its students.
Three ways outcomes figures are presented better than reality
Combining many fields into one figure. A school with a few fields with very good outcomes can pull the overall rate up, hiding other fields that are much weaker. When an admissions page has only a whole-school figure, the mentor treats it as promotion rather than data, and looks for the figure for the right field.
Leaving out people not looking for work. Some reports remove from the denominator those "not seeking work", such as people taking a year off, travelling or preparing for further study. This is statistically reasonable, but if the excluded group is large, the employment rate looks higher than the reality feels. A good report states the size of that group.
Choosing a favourable time frame. A school may publish its best year's rate, or choose a later survey point to make the figure look better. The mentor reads at least two or three consecutive years and checks whether the survey point stays the same. A figure that is stable over several years is more trustworthy than one standout year.
How to read it properly. There is no need to doubt every figure; just read the small print under the table. Most of the important information is there: the survey sample, definitions, timing and response rate.
How the mentor brings outcomes into the decision
In the Global Gate Pass school comparison table, outcomes are a separate axis, scored at programme level. Dương Bảo Khánh, who is responsible for Alumni and careers, reviews the outcomes information for programmes on the shortlist together with the regional mentor, because this is also the area that will accompany the student in later years of study.
The weight of the outcomes axis depends on the student. For a student planning postgraduate study, the main question is the rate of students continuing their studies and research opportunities, not immediate employment. For a student who wants to work right after graduating, internships and industry links carry more weight. For a student without a clear direction yet, the mentor suggests a moderate weight and gives priority to programmes with internships.
The mentor does not promise jobs or settlement through a field or a school. Outcomes are a probability that depends heavily on the student: how they study, where they intern, how they build connections. The report only shows how favourable the environment is.
An illustrative scenario: two programmes both reporting ninety per cent
A hypothetical example: two programmes in the same field at two schools both report that ninety per cent of students are employed or in further study. The first surveyed fifteen months after graduation, had a response rate above half, and gives a separate figure for full-time work related to the field. The second surveyed after six months, gives no response rate, and combines every kind of employment with further study.
The two figures are the same, but only the first can be read. For the second programme, the mentor emails to ask more and scores it cautiously on the outcomes axis until an answer arrives. If the school cannot answer, that is information too.
If your family would like help reading the outcomes reports of programmes you are considering, you can book a free 60-minute first consultation through the form on the Contact page, with the names of the programmes.
Frequently asked questions
Are the starting salaries in the report reliable?
They are worth referring to when the report states how many people answered the salary question and the figure is a median rather than a mean. Salaries in the host country also have little bearing on income after returning to Vietnam, so the mentor does not use them as a main criterion.
Should a school that publishes no outcomes report be ruled out?
Not necessarily, especially in Europe and East Asia, where publication is less standardised. The mentor asks the department directly and looks for alumni. If there is no information at all, the school is scored cautiously on the outcomes axis.
Do university rankings reflect outcomes?
Partly. Some rankings have an employer reputation indicator, but it is measured at school level and based on opinion surveys. The outcomes report of the specific programme is far more concrete.
Are a field's outcomes in Vietnam the same as abroad?
Usually not. Hiring demand, attitudes to qualifications and the degree to which employers distinguish between schools differ in Vietnam from the host country. Students planning to return should also ask about the alumni network in Vietnam and domestic employers.
Do outcomes reports help with choosing a field?
They help, but should not be the only basis. Choosing a field should start from the student's abilities and interests; outcomes help compare programmes within the same field and show which fields need extra internships or certification to get a good job.
Should one alumnus's account be trusted over the report?
An account gives details a report does not, but it is only one case. The mentor uses accounts to ask better questions, and reports to see the overall picture. Hearing from two or three people is more reliable than one.